Why Simranjit Singh Mann fared badly?
From: Balbir Singh Sooch firstname.lastname@example.org
To: Amandeep Singh <email@example.com>
Date: Mar 3, 2007
Subject: Re: Why Simranjit Singh Mann fared badly?
Mailed by: gmail.com
Balbir Singh Sooch
Dear Amandeep Singh ji and like others,
You are saying same thing other way around. It is open fact being
admitted & proclaimed so by the main functionaries of his party who
encircled him till date for the reasons best known to them. The
voters very well understood all this from them and they passed their
positive verdict coolly. Now some young 'killer' is likely to take
over the party to do the assigned task through his obedient team of
the government 'Cats'.
Sardar Badal and his party men due to apprehension of danger to
their lives fell into the lap of another Hindu communalist party
i.e. BJP and still they continue so at the cost of Sikh tenets
knowing well that there is no other alternative under the
circumstances and its effect is visible on the young Sikh generation
& nobody escaped from it. To my mind, the projection of "Scha Sauda"
to that extent amounts to confession for our own failure on
religious front if "Scha Sauda" effect is real and true. Other
apprehensions may take place in religious field and would prove
dangerous thereafter can not be ruled out.
Ultimately, Sikhs are to be sufferers
and the political professional, businessmen, greedy etc nothing to
lose and Deras etc will replace the glory of Sikhism and
pessimistically it can be said that everything is now in the hand of
nature i.e. to me GOD. The followers of ritualistic way of life are
playing their own game as suits to them. Thank God, you are among
those who are sitting in heaven and questioning everyone here and
commenting freely without following any ideology and contribution
except playing the tactics of divide and rule with your dollar power
but at whose instance only God knows? I am very poor to comment and
play the game under the influence of such power.
You are also playing something fishy
like others and did not choose to comment and make a point of
discussion on my comments already sent to all as under:
NOW IT IS CLEAR THAT
THE ENEMY IS WITHIN
Sardar Simranjit Singh Mann remained encircled by his critics within
and outside India and his own party functionaries. What are the
reasons as to why he could not come out of it due to his own
spinelessness despite being sincere to the cause or something else?
It is all premature to discuss in detail at this stage. The way he
is about to leave the command of his party further raises doubts and
suspicion about him and his close functionaries as to whose instance
he does all this?
In brief, it can safely be said that his critics sitting in safe
heavens within or out of India and his associates proved like
'contract killers' for Sikhs all over in the past in the name of
achieving goal of "Khalistan" but their real ulterior motives are to
do selfish professional politics to collect dollars and protect
their properties and business especially owned out of Punjab by
remaining in news and supporting anti-Sikh forces.
No doubt, in the process, the Indian agencies stand exposed and the
rest game of guessing, researching of unchecked killings the
minorities in India under unnumbered pretexts shall continue by the
impartial human activists and historians of the World till the
freedom of all.
I like to reproduce my brief article in this connection as under:
Punjab political analysis in context of Sikhs
the confused state of Sikh politics is further being exploited for
personal reasons, keeping in mind the forth coming
assembly election. The opportunists and greedy are busy to get their
presence marked for the benefit of anti-Panthic forces. Now, who is
agent of Indian agencies? It is difficult to say anything
specifically at this junction. It is what the situation, the
agencies wanted to create to harm the Sikhs politically. Who are
assisting to target the Sikhs from within or outside at the instance
of the agencies? Is it a fight between the stooges of the agencies?
Are the political statements being given in state of frustration
frequently by those who feel ignored by their masters at this stage?
Who will awaken the Sikhs to answer these questions so that the
position of Sikhs does not deteriorate and dilute further
Who are advising Sikhs to ignore both Sardar Simranjit Singh Mann
and Sardar Parkash Singh Badal in Indian style of democratic process
and in the same breath pleading for peaceful means to achieve an
end, they are biggest agent of Indian agencies as they leave no path
to toe or methods for Sikhs to choose to get a respectable political
status within India except saying to adopt to do or die means.
has been said earlier, Sardar Simranjit Singh Mann is only sincere,
relevant, capable and available in field i.e.
Punjab (India) as a leader of Sikh masses who is symbol of Sikh
demands/identity/aspirations. By putting your weight to his side,
means you are voting genuinely in favour of your own aspirations and
at the same time you are also supporting the cause of humanity.
No-doubt, in the process, the anti Sikh forces may celebrate
politically wherever they may be.
But there are chances that Sardar Simranjit Singh Mann's team might
be a deciding force as to who should rule over
Punjab after assembly election. It is all depends upon as to how the
each voter feels to be a part of such a just force and cast his
vote? In other words, Sardar Simranjit Singh Mann can be a balancing
force and in case voters opt for his team then need not repent later
on in this polluted democratic system of India and at least can rely
case the voters opt for Badal (BJP) or Congress means no change in
system of arbitrary rule which means a dictatorship of 'One Party'
and again society has to face a rule of anarchy and unchecked
corruption all over and balancing force shall be missing altogether.
It all depends upon the way the voter is being educated to cast his
Now question is as to how to escape from the enemies of progressive
democracy based on balancing force i.e. the value based force of
peace and justice for all, is main hurdle at this stage as the
entire democratic system of
India is nothing but only a agency network in real sense. It is also
a main obstacle to create 'public opinion'. The name of the
democratic system of India including Panjab can be called 'National
Terrorism' i.e. the worst type of largest hidden dictatorship of the
The Sikhs who know and admit that there is no alternative and
sincere leadership available except Sardar Simranjit Singh Mann but
still they prefer to criticize him for nothing but only to please
their masters to get their presence marked as per the set directives
and policies of Indian agencies matter for the purpose. Who will
advise to such agents to amend? Only time may answer or tell about
FROM: Amandeep Singh firstname.lastname@example.org
Date: Mar 3, 2007
Subject: Why Simranjit Singh Mann fared badly?
Mailed by: gmail.com
have seen numerous emails on the topic that why Simranjit Singh Mann
fared badly? Many reasons have been given, but no one has touched
the central issue. BADAL has very simple sentence to negate Mann "MANN
is a CONGRESS AGENT" Inspite of all work, Mann has
never been able to counter due to limited resources. Badal's
propaganda machine is very well oiled due to reasons below:
He is able to collect enough resources (people in government jobs
and resultant money) while in power.
2. For other 5 years when he is not in power,
he is able to sustain himself with SGPC resources.
Badal spends lot of resources on SGPC elections where only 25% voter
turn up for elections.
local Gurdwara elections in small colonies are influenced by Badal
Even BJP takes interest in local suburban gurdwara elections these
days, as gurdwaras are democratic while Mandirs are owned by Pujaris.
So village folk and even educated city dwellers do not even consider
voting for Mann.
Mr. ADS MANGAT JI,
Mar 4, 2007
Subject Re: Re: NOW IT IS CLEAR THAT THE ENEMY IS WITHIN
Balbir Singh Sooch
Mailed by: gmail.com
You should have introduced me about being you are so great at the
first instance itself and unnecessarily started questioning and
testing me without having time to read and thirst to know anything
to its grassroots level. Once I happened to see a person haughty,
not so fair in colour, having very good height, clean shaven
ignorantly ignoring all sitting around, only talking softly to the
man to whom he might have hired for his egoist reasons and only
replying ha, hi, hu, za to give impression that he knows only
English and others sitting around might not be able to understand
his language. Are you not same or similar type of person?
Anyway you may or you may not be the same or similar type of person
but it is clear that you are not less egoist. Moreover, you may in
intoxication of your richness but afraid to write your full name and
address while talking about Sikhi and for the people.
Nothing can be expected in the larger interest from the persons like
you as you reacted without going through my writings about Sikhi or
for the people. Now you may understand that the real problem is
created by the egoists like you and me and nobody is bothered for
Sikhi and the people.
still wish to pay regards to you to satisfy your ego. Thanks for
understanding the problem.
more egoists and opportunists may come forward to see the clash of
words and give it new turn of bloodshed with a new agenda and
questionnaires to set a stage again for their past days glory
without caring about Sikhi or the people. Who shall be behind all
this again, time has come to find out and understand the culprits.
It may be another challenge before the present government and its
agencies to keep peace in State of Punjab.
Balbir Singh Sooch, Advocate, Ludhiana